Showing posts with label PYB 535 Reading Reflection. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PYB 535 Reading Reflection. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 7, 2007

Anxiety and Cognitive Behavior

I wrote this essay for a graduate course last Spring at Antioch University called Autism Spectrum Disorder Graduate Certificate. I am still trying to have the department delete the word 'disorder.'


The Reader's Digest Great Encyclopedic Dictionary defines the psychological concept of ANXIETY as "a tense emotional state characterized by fear and apprehension."

Persons with Asperger's Syndrome, as well those with the high IQ autism, often struggle with anxiety and depression. Indeed, emotions are a challenge that can lead to depression as well as anxiety.

In the not-too-distant past, the flat emotional affect (facial, body and gestural display) of Auties and Aspies led clinicians to believe that we were cold, aloof and completely not empathetic.

Part of me understands this and part of me is angered by the judgement inherent in this.

It is well and good to create positive strategies, to use role modelling, videography, prosocial skills training, and pragmatic language skills. BUT if children are experiencing anxiety and depression, then that BY DEFINITION means that there are emotions running rampant in the heart and minds of Auties and Aspies regardless of expressive language deficits.

Then I ask myself, and by extension I would ask the researchers, what CAUSES the anxiety?

My answer is fear. Just as sensory filters can be different from the majority (neurotypicals or NT's), so can emotional filters. Both emotions and sensory input affect the central nervous system, the auto immune system, and the endocrine system.

We are electrical beings, our atoms and molecules radiating energy from conception to death, and probably beyond. So neurotypicals intuitively receive emotional signals from one another.

Which brings me to Theory of Mind, which is like an Abbott and Costello film...Abbot says 'We have to get back to the car.' Costello replies 'I know that.' Then the repartee begins...'How do you know that? I just thought it.' Costello quips 'I don't know, but I know you were thinking.' Then is progresses: 'How do you know I was thinking?' ' How do you know I was thinking what you were thinking before I told you I know.'

I am paraphrasing their routine, but Theory of Mind hypothesizes that NT's develop this trait naturally, while Auties do not.

BUT, if there are buried or inaccessible thoughts, can not there be buried and inaccessible emotions ? From whence comes this anxiety? From whence comes this depression? There must be interior knowledge of some sort for this response to exist.

What if, like sensory integrative dysfunction wherein all the senses are over aroused or under stimulated, what if emotions lack the same filtering constellation? We feel emotions all right, but like flickering lights and noisy crowds these electrical emissions overwhelm, and the mind, which is supposed to develop ToM intuitively, creates a protective barrier instead?




I know when emotions are running rampant. I have mentioned to others that walking along a city sidewalk is akin to a Coast Guard cutter breaking through the Artic ice flow. BUT I cannot interpret them. Indeed they often feel like an attack. This is a large part of why I never attended autism support group meetings before last year.



On the one side, I was acting Autie by keeping to myself and learning by my self. On the other side I have interacted with enough parents to know that fear and anxiety on THEIR part fills a room with tension-which I do not interpret well or handle (filter) well. So why would I want to attend a meeting with that type of energy?



Which brings me back to underlying emotions and from whence do they come?



Lately I often think that all the therapists, psychologists and researchers are looking at this neurological difference from such a global position that they, the NT's of the world, cannot see the details of what is happening.



I need to digress and tell a personal story here and it is so hard that verbal and written language is so linear. I wish you could simply plug into my mind and see all the pictures, but linear is what I have so here is the story.



I used to meditate alot in my twenties. Having five children precludes that opportunity right now, but just before I got married I was soaking in a hot tub relaxing, with candlelight and Pachabel's Canon in D playing. Then I had this weird experience, wherein I was in this dark, quiet and gentle place. I had no worries, I felt safe and content. Then I felt attacked, pushed and shoved and squashed. Then in my mind there was all this noise and almost shouting and people calling for help and then bright sharp lights assaulted my senses and I was cold and alone and scared.



When i aroused from this experience I had the thought that this was a birth experience. I asked my Mom about our birth, and I discovered an incredible fact: my Mom and I both almost died during labor. There were indeed doctors and nurses yelling and as is typical of birth in 1950's hospitals, lots of bright lighting and noises.



This experience and new knowledge led me to visualize birth, and when I had my own first baby I set up a birthing room at home with a midwife, and I had low lighting, gentle music playing, and calm loving attendants. What a different experience my son had!



But I use this visualization in talks about autism. I ask attendees to close their eyes and imagine the safest, warm, shadowed place they could. I ask them to imagine feeling so contented, no hunger, no thirst, no cares or concerns. I ask them to imagine peace and safety. This is harder than one might think. Then I have them imagine that the room suddenly closes in on them, that it shrinks and tightens and eventually squishes them. I have them try to think about a loud experience such as a construction site and city traffic, and suddenly being thrust from safety into extraordinarily bright sunlight, sharp cold, lonliness, hunger and scratchy rough clothing.



Then I ask them for what this guided meditation might signify. It amazes me how quickly so many, especially women, respond with the understanding that I am describing the birth process, what it looks like from the inside, from the baby's perspective.



So now we come back to the highly sensitive body, the greatly sensitive emotional state of a neonate. Can we see and understand from where comes the first fear, the first anxiety? What others percieve of as joyful and fulfilling can be a nightmare for the littlest of us.


I think it is fantastic that Cognitive Behavioral Therapies can help us reduce and redirect anxiety. But until we understand how primal these feelings are then we are not healing and addressing the underlying or root cause.



We all need to feel safe and loved. We all need a sense of peace and if not happiness at least contentment. When a newborn feels attacked, then the shut down and closed filtering system for sensory overload becomes understandable. Teaching strategies for behavioral and emotional responses is a significant help.



Demonstrating safety and restructuring memory may go a longer way toward helping an Autie or Aspie feel safe and confident enough to pursue life, liberty, and happiness, in one's family, one's culture, and society.

Saturday, November 3, 2007

When in Rome, When in Autie Land


I love Tony Attwood.
This is not Tony Attwood. It is Don Adams of the 1960's TV show, Get Smart, and he comes into this story. Later. (The Blogging Editor doesn't let me place photographs where I want them.)

But back to Tony Attwood.
I have not always loved him. I thought perhaps he was a bit arrogant a bit presumptuous. But I know him better now. I have read his latest book The Complete Guide To Asperger's Syndrome and I have also had the honor of attending his conference in Boston this past September. Carol Gray was his co-presenter and the Autism Association of New England sponsored the conference, for which there were almost 1,000 attendees.

But I still have difficulty with some psychological presumptions. But to be fair, perhaps that is because Auties and Aspies are each different with a different constellation of affects, affectations, and affections.

Theory of Mind is the concept that people can use past experiences and knowledge to predict and/or explain another's behavior. It is the idea that one can figure out, perhaps, what another person feels, thinks, desires and believes. Apparently the majority of people, the 'neurotypicals,' can perform this grand feat at a young age and that it begins with pretend play.

An example for pretend play is the child's ability to take anything and transform it, for instance, using a banana to be a dump truck, or a teddy bear doll to represent a mother or father.

For me, this is tantamount to lying. Truly. One should use a tool for its purpose, there is an inherent rightness in that. So perhaps it is the NT child whose perceptions are squirrelly and it is only because the majority plays this way that it can be considered normal.

What is normal? It is only a statistic, but humans set much store by such numbers and for me that is a sign of their insecurity...If everyone has a car, and I get a car (even if it is a decrepit 1986 Ponitac Skylark) then I fit in. If I get a Lamborgini, then I not only fit in overall, I excel somehow.

But does anyone besides environmentalists consider the miracle of feet? I suppose weight loss specialists would also value the gift of mobilization.

My first pretend play insight was from television, which I knew was fiction even when my peers did not and still today many cannot tell the difference. Hmmm. There was a comedy show, Get Smart, and in it Maxwell Smart and Agent 99 had many "tools" that were unusual and that parodied the technology in espionage. I was totally fascinated by the idea that a person might take off a shoe and talk into it just like a telephone! To this day I will mimic the actor, whipping off anything--even a shoe--and bark out "Hello, Chief? This is Max!" I think it is particularly funny when I actually do that with a phone handset or cell phone. (Of course it is best when someone remembers the show!)

Perhaps this attention to playing with shoes is what instigated my interest in the social world in junior high school. Personally I think that it is poor timing for figuring out there are other important persons as SO MUCH goes on in adolescence.

This blog is too long...

Anyway, there is this game, a test, that psychology researchers use to determine if a child has Theory of Mind or whether it may be considered a "deficit." They are all complex, but the researchers think these set-ups are simple. Apparently many children already understand this game and on a type of 'auto-pilot' can predict behavior.

But I would like to suggest a different tact.

Sally and Ann are friends. Sally has a basket and a marble. Ann has a box. Sally leaves Ann alone, at which point Ann takes the marble and hides it in her box. The Great And Ominous Question that 'proves' Theory of Mind is: When Sally returns, where will she think that the marble is?

This, of course, is the wrong question.

Here it is from My Side of the Mountain.

How do you know that Sally and Ann are friends? How long have they known one another? Are they neighbors or school pals? Are they wearing similar clothing? Do they really have similar interests, especially since one has a box and one has a basket? Why does one have a box and one a basket? Is Sally related to Little Red Riding Hood who also had a basket? If there is only a marble in the basket, why? Misuse of space, if you ask me, as well as misuse of purpose. Girls don't play marbles, they play jacks. Boys play marbles, so why does Sally have a marble? Did she steal it from her brother? Does she have a brother? What color is it? Is it a cats' eye? Is it one of those big ones with lots of colors? If Sally and Ann are friends, why does Sally leave Ann alone, without any explanation? And if Ann is her friend, why does she take, or steal, the marble? Sally returns without any explanation and Ann doesn't even say "hi." Aren't they supposed to say "hi" if they are friends? I could generate another dozen question but you get the idea, don't you?

And you want me to think about Sally's thinking?

I have had tests like this, and truthfully, True and False or Multiple Choice questions are the bane of my academic life. There are just too many "threads" to follow, too many word choices. Connotations rule the speech world, and they are dangerous for me.

So I would like the Tony Attwoods to think (ToM?) about a different type of processing. We know that Aspies prefer to see details rather than the global picture. Could that not be true about these silly games? What if Aspies know they are games and are trying to figure out the POINT? Maybe the question should be....What is the therapist thinking you are thinking about this game?

And this face recognition/eye gaze thingee...What if, from birth, Aspie babies learned from the Brazelton Baby Dance that eyes lie? That faces don't always reflect true feelings and that the people closest to them HIDE themselves? What if that takes the place of cuteness learning (ToM) so early, so innately, that hiding one's self is the impetus for gaze aversion? One is asked to listen...the ears are on the side of the head, and the sound comes out the mouth. The mouth is statistically where Aspies tend to watch. That would not be a problem for deaf persons, why is it considered a problem for Aspies? That is from where the sound emanates! I don't hear with my eyes! In fact, I have to consciously close out visual input to listen with my whole heart and mind. Is a little gaze aversion too much to ask of NT'S?

Looking into one's eyes is paramount to gazing into the soul, and my rule is that this type of intimacy is reserved for those whom I love. I make eye contact, as painful and embarrassing as it can be, because it is expected. But I reiterate...people lie through their eyes and facial expressions. I often reflect that how a person uses their HANDS tells more about their true Nature.

I will confess to this: In Psychology Today, a few years back, there was a mini-test of Simon Baron-Cohen's work, about 100 faces with emotions assigned to them. I have been a performing artist, I read alot, and I watch lots of films. I thought I would "ace" this test.

I got four faces correct. And this summer I read that they, Baron-Cohen's team in England, have identified like 451 different emotions. Like, we NEED that many? Isn't life hard enough?

Which brings up the issue--WHY DO PECS BOARDS ONLY HAVE 3 or 4 EMOTIONS ON THEM? Sad, Angry or Happy...how about BORED? Joyful? And why not use REAL faces not line drawings? Aren't Real Faces and Real Emotions the POINT?

I digress.

There are these thingees labelled emotions. Sigh. Aspies are a paradigm shift. I prefer to laugh and dance at funerals because the person is FREE. I cry at movies, but not in life. I think, though, that Aspies have not the monopoly on this difficulty with emotions.

The entire male portion of the human race also has trouble. I asked my husband for like 10 years, "How are you feeling?" I ask this of many men. Now most people actually misrepresent the Truth, but men almost always say FINE. They are thinking about PHYSICALLY feeling fine. I learned the social lesson shortly after graduating college...the question refers to emotional feelings. HOW ARE YOU FEELING? can be a mere greeting (a concept which took me a long time to understand and is one with which I still struggle) or a genuine inquiry.

A wedding is joyful, but people cry. A birth is painful but people smile and rejoice. Time is an invention of industry and its requirements of people, and being late for work or appointments makes for Major Stress, but it is not REAL.

So I wait. Tell me a story. Tell me the story of the odd connections and leapings and rules of the majority. At the rate of autism incidence, it would be good to understand the Typically Developing. Auties may be the majority someday and I think that we think that you all think maybe we could learn not to judge, not to use sarcasm, not to tease or bully.
You think?